Let me be clear upfront: I’m a Red Wing fan. But like any long relationship with a brand, it’s complicated. I’ve been through multiple pairs of Red Wings over the years, and while they’ve never let me down completely, they haven’t quite given me everything I need either. Consider this my honest assessment with a few suggestions for improvement.
The Gold Standard: Red Wing 8249 Steel Toe Moc Toe Supersole
This is where it all started for me. Back in my NYC film production days (working as a studio manager – worst job I ever had), a coworker introduced me to the Red Wing 8249 Steel Toe Moc Toe Supersole. I believe I found these online again recently with just a slightly different tread pattern, and they don’t have the padded ankle – which I actually prefer.
These boots were absolutely perfect for what I needed at the time. Long days on set moving equipment, never worrying about crushing my toes under a heavy marble slab or steel beam. But here’s what made them special: they were work boots that didn’t look like work boots. Sharp enough to wear out for drinks after the shoot wrapped, stylish enough for weekend bar hopping. That’s the Red Wing magic right there.
For that period of my life, these were hands-down the best boots I ever owned. The construction was solid, the comfort was outstanding, and they had that indefinable cool factor that Red Wing has mastered.
The Problems: They weren’t waterproof (deal-breaker for my current lifestyle), the soles were slippery in snow, and they couldn’t be easily slipped on or off. When you’re constantly going in and out of the house – multiple times per hour – lacing up boots gets old fast.
The Vibram Experiment: Red Wing Heritage 4183 Roughneck
I thought the lack of aggressive tread on the 8249s was limiting me, so when Banana Republic started carrying the Red Wing Heritage 4183 moc toe with Vibram lug sole, I was thrilled. Red Wing appears to carry this model again, which is great news.
I made a sizing mistake here – bought the 8.5 since it was the same size I wore in the 8249, but I should have gone with the 8 since there was no steel toe taking up space. Live and learn.
The Reality Check: Those Vibram lugs looked great on paper but were a nightmare in practice. They got clogged with mud and dirt constantly, and since the boot still wasn’t waterproof, I couldn’t really use them in the rough terrain where those lugs would actually be useful. The 8249 remained my go-to boot.
Sometimes you think you need more tread, more grip, more aggressive everything – but simple and effective often wins out.
The Workhorse: Red Wing Dynaforce
When we were building our house and I needed something truly waterproof for wet and muddy conditions, I went with 8″ Red Wing Dynaforce waterproof boots. These weren’t about style – they were pure function. And they delivered.
The Dynaforce boots held up incredibly well through the construction process. I still use them today, but only when I know I won’t have to come inside for an extended period. They’re not slip-ons, so they fall into that category of “great boots that don’t work for my current lifestyle of constant in-and-out.”
But here’s what Red Wing got right with these: they’re genuinely waterproof, built like tanks, and comfortable for long work days. They prove Red Wing can make excellent waterproof boots – they just need to apply that technology to their more stylish models.
The One That Got Away: Red Wing Classic Moc
The Red Wing Classic Moc keeps catching my eye as a potential solution. It’s got that classic Red Wing style I love, and it’s a bit more refined than the 8249. But here’s the thing – it’s not waterproof, and it’s not a slip-on. For my current lifestyle, those are non-negotiable features.
This boot represents the Red Wing dilemma perfectly: they make beautiful, well-constructed boots that are almostperfect for what I need. Almost.
What Red Wing Gets Right
Let me give credit where it’s due. Red Wing boots are built to last. My 8249s are still going strong after years of abuse. The leather quality is excellent, the construction is solid, and they have a style that works in multiple settings – from job site to bar stool.
The moc toe design is particularly genius. It’s distinctive enough to be interesting, practical enough for real work, and stylish enough for casual wear. It’s that perfect intersection of form and function.
What Red Wing Needs to Figure Out
Here’s my wishlist for Red Wing, straight from the heart of a devoted customer:
1. Waterproof Moc Toe Chelsea Boots: This is my holy grail. Red Wing does make Chelsea boots and slip-on styles, and they do make waterproof boots – but they don’t make a waterproof moc toe Chelsea. Take the 8249, make it waterproof, add Chelsea boot elastic sides for easy on/off. I would buy this boot in a heartbeat.
2. Waterproof Everything: I believe in being prepared. You always end up outdoors in bad weather when you least expect it. Red Wing makes great waterproof boots for serious outdoor work, but it would be fantastic if they could add waterproofing to boots that aren’t necessarily intended for heavy outdoor use. Sometimes your “light duty” day turns into trudging through mud.
3. Better Style Integration: They have the technology and the materials – now just combine them in more versatile packages. Moc toe + waterproof + easy on/off shouldn’t be too much to ask from a company this established.
The Bottom Line
Red Wing makes the best work boots I’ve ever owned, but they’re stuck in their ways. The 8249 Steel Toe Moc Toe Supersole remains my benchmark for what a perfect work boot should feel like. Everything else I’ve tried has been measured against it.
But times change, and needs evolve. I’ve gone from film sets to country living, from style-over-function to needing boots that can handle mud, water, and constant on-and-off wear. Red Wing has the craftsmanship and the style – now they just need to adapt to modern work-life demands.
Red Wing, if you’re listening: Make me a waterproof Chelsea version of the 8249 with that same Supersole, and I’ll be a customer for life. Until then, I’ll keep searching for the perfect boot while wearing my trusty 8249s whenever I can get away with it.
A Quick Note on Sizing: Even with the same brand and model, boots in the same size can fit completely differently. I’ve had one pair hurt my feet terribly while another pair of the exact same boot in the same size was perfectly comfortable. Quality control varies, leather stretches differently, or who knows what – just something to keep in mind when ordering online.
Sometimes the best boots are the ones that make you realize how hard it is to find their equal.
Even that's Odd 
Leave a comment